The Constant Reader

Here is a section from Charles Wright's book-length poem, Littlefoot:

Orpheus walked, the poets say, down to the black river.
Nobody recognized him,
Of course, and the boat came,
the gondola with its singular oarsman,
And the crowd got in, a thousand souls,
So light that the boat drew no water, not even a half-inch.
On the other side, the one paved road, and they took it.

Afterward, echoes of thge great song webbed in their ears,
They took the same road back to the waiting gondola,
The two of them,
the first to ever have returned to the soot-free shore.
The oarsman's stroke never faltered, and he hummed the song
He had caught the faint edges of
from the distant, marble halls.
It won't work, he thought to himself, it won't work. And it didn't.

I love this, with its image of the boatload of souls that weighs not a thing, and with the implacable Charon just doing his job, enjoying Orpheus's song but sure "it won't work." Is he cynical, or just knowing, like the poet who knows that poetry never makes anything happen? Perhaps he's sad that this is the case, perhaps not. So the lovers are doomed from the start. Then I saw the Met Opera's HD live transmission of Gluck's , "Orpheus ed Eurydice" in which quite the reverse happens: Orpheus (sung by the incomparable Stephanie Blythe) gives up and looks back at his love, as he has promised not to do, But all is not lost; Amor is so impressed with Orpheus's devotion that he descends from the heavens to announce that Eurydice is spared and the lovers are to be reunited. Eurydice comes back to life and all celebrate. In short, it works.
Yes, I suppose this is wonderful--but Wright's vision is so much more satisfactory, is it not?